Fallen tree -- need advice - Dorkiphus.net
Navigation » Dorkiphus.net > Miscellaneous Discussions > Miscellaneous Discussions » Fallen tree -- need advice

Miscellaneous Discussions Off Topic (OT) items that really don't fit into any other Category

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 06-11-2021, 05:06 PM
BillC's Avatar
BillC BillC is offline
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Silver Spring, MD
Posts: 1,138
BillC
Default Fallen tree -- need advice

We came home from work a little while ago to find that a dead tree has fallen from the park land behind our house into our back yard, smashing the fence and a tree inside our yard in the process.

My wife called the park service, and they basically told her to go pound sand. They claimed it was an Act of God, and that they aren't responsible for the damage or the cleanup. Which sounds like total BS to us.

Are they responsible for the damage caused by their trees, or can they hide behind this "Act of God" nonsense? I was always taught that if something of yours causes damage to someone else, you are responsible for it. Isn't that the case here?

Also, the park service came through the park last summer, taking down a number of trees (trunks and limbs still laying everywhere). My wife pointed out to them that there were/are several dead trees standing that weren't marked to be taken down, and this tree is one of those that she pointed out. Since they acknowledged the trees were dead but left them anyway, doesn't that make them responsible, at least through willful negligence?
__________________
2016 GT4 warp 7
1999 SPB warp 2, maybe
1973 914 2.0 1/2 impulse

Previous:
1973 914 1.7 1/4 impulse
2012 Cayman R warp 4
2006 Cayman S warp 3
1966 911 stuck in space dock
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 06-11-2021, 05:39 PM
Kk1340 Kk1340 is offline
 
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: Leesburg,va
Posts: 61
Kk1340
Default

As a arborist in Virginia, I believe that if you did not send them a certified letter about the tree in question, once it crosses the property line it becomes your tree. I know the live trees especially during storms that it becomes yours when it crosses property lines. Your case is tricky because you said your wife told guys working on park land about the tree . They could say they cut down some trees and the one that fell just died. Insurance would handle the fence and clean up but you would have to pay your deductible. This is in Virginia and am not sure about Maryland. Good luck
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 06-11-2021, 06:20 PM
Vicegrip's Avatar
Vicegrip Vicegrip is offline
Porkchop & SGB for prez!
 
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: The other Woodstock.
Posts: 13,027
Vicegrip has six HoF threadsVicegrip has six HoF threadsVicegrip has six HoF threadsVicegrip has six HoF threadsVicegrip has six HoF threadsVicegrip has six HoF threads
Default

I second the info on the law and trees. I have dealt with this both personally when the next door tree fell on my old falls church house and professionally on managed property.
For almost all conditions the cost of the clean up is yours. Your insurance should cover it (if it is worth filing a claim)

Exceptions to the laws exist but are rare and specific. As noted if the tree was professionally deemed a hazard and the land / tree owner legally notified they assume the liability. You can’t just say “That tree looks dangerous” and assign liability.

There are some other weaknesses in the laws who’s roots go back to King George but I would bet going after a government entity over a tree cleanup and fence repair might not have a good ROI.
__________________
http://vimeo.com/29896988

"There is grandeur in this view of life...." Darwin.

The mountains are calling and I must go.

“The earth has music for those who listen”
Shakespeare.

You Matter.
(Until you multiply yourself times the speed of light squared. Then you Energy)
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 06-11-2021, 07:13 PM
Trak Ratt's Avatar
Trak Ratt Trak Ratt is offline
Senior Curmudgeon
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Alexandria/Mt. Vernon, Va
Posts: 27,202
Trak Ratt has one HoF thread
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kk1340 View Post
As a arborist in Virginia, I believe that if you did not send them a certified letter about the tree in question, once it crosses the property line it becomes your tree. I know the live trees especially during storms that it becomes yours when it crosses property lines. Your case is tricky because you said your wife told guys working on park land about the tree . They could say they cut down some trees and the one that fell just died. Insurance would handle the fence and clean up but you would have to pay your deductible. This is in Virginia and am not sure about Maryland. Good luck
X3
__________________
David

I hope to arrive to my death, late, in love, and a little drunk!

Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand... Homer Simpson

"That's what's keeping me out of F1.... Too much mental maturity...." N0tt0n

Some cause happiness wherever they go; others whenever they go.

CHAOS, PANIC, AND DISORDER my work here is done...

Live without pretending, Love without depending, Listen without defending, Speak without offending
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 06-11-2021, 07:15 PM
Vicegrip's Avatar
Vicegrip Vicegrip is offline
Porkchop & SGB for prez!
 
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: The other Woodstock.
Posts: 13,027
Vicegrip has six HoF threadsVicegrip has six HoF threadsVicegrip has six HoF threadsVicegrip has six HoF threadsVicegrip has six HoF threadsVicegrip has six HoF threads
Default

Got me thinking. As said had a tree fall on the old house. Clipped off some of the extended eves of a non truss roof and bent up the railing on the front porch. The tree fell during hurricane Isabel and due to a landscaper cutting 100% of the roots right up to the trunk on the side away from my house. It was only a matter of time for it to fall. The neighbor ( named Isabel BTW) paid to have the tree brush chipped had removed out of good will. I bucked and cleaned up the rest for firewood. Insurance waved the deductible and paid out way too much IMO. Made a nice profit doing the work in house and had 2 big catered street parties of the type that were talked about 15 years later thanks to Isabel (and Isabel).

Had a big white oak that 50/50 straddled the back prop line. It fell on the house behind me and fell hard. Split the top floor of a $750,000 house in two. Homeowner calls me screaming that I need to call mi insurance and get the tree removed!1!!!!1!1! Once she was out of breath I explained the law. She was not amused and I learned some new cuss words. The sad part is the house was a rental and the renters real nice folks, the owner not so much. Suffice to say I did not cover anything and the owner, or her lawyers, never contacted me again.
Talked the tree removal company to crane the trunk sections into my backyard. More firewood!
__________________
http://vimeo.com/29896988

"There is grandeur in this view of life...." Darwin.

The mountains are calling and I must go.

“The earth has music for those who listen”
Shakespeare.

You Matter.
(Until you multiply yourself times the speed of light squared. Then you Energy)
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 06-11-2021, 08:14 PM
Patrick3000's Avatar
Patrick3000 Patrick3000 is offline
I need another Porsche
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Bethesda
Posts: 2,639
Patrick3000
Default

Bill,

You are lucky the tree hit and damaged your fence. Your homeowners insurance will cover the tree removal and replacement of the fence. The insurance company will likely deprecate the reimbursement for the fence depending on how old the fence is and the material that the fence is made from. Do not clean up the area until after you have filed an insurance claim and they have inspected the damage. If the tree had fallen and caused no damage to your property the entire clean up would be on you. It all depends on where the tree lands as to who is the responsible party. The downside of filing an insurance claim is that your rate may increase and/or the insurance company could possibly drop you altogether if you have filed other claims.

Don’t ask how I know, good luck.
__________________
Karl

18 GT3T -
11 997 C2S - Aerokit Cup
04 996 GT3 - HPDE
19 Beetle Conv - Hers
13 S60 T5 - Kids
08 535i 6 Spd - DD
01 Bullitt Mustang - Kids

Sold: 86 951, 14 911-50, 79 911SC, 74 914/6, 11 997.2 C2S, 88 944, 16 GT4, 13 Boxster, 1973 914/4 2.0, 1980 911SC ROW w/3.2, 77 911S Targa, 1970 914GT 3.2, 71 914/4 2.4, 76 912E, 89 944S2, 1980 924 Turbo, 98 Boxster, 70 911T, 72 914, 75 914, 73 914, 87 944, 74 911, 72 914 - 97 M3, 06 M3, 95 M3, 98 328is, 95 530i, 95 328is
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 06-12-2021, 09:54 AM
HoodPin's Avatar
HoodPin HoodPin is offline
Building a Worm Hole.....
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Monrovia, MD
Posts: 10,558
HoodPin
Default

^^ X2
__________________
- Tony P.

Currently
- 1984 944 SP2 racer
- 1977 911 KM Special vintage racer
- 1989 944S2
- 2012 Cayman R (also the wife's)
- 2000 Boxster S (the wife's)

- 1995 993 (garage queen)
- 1979 RX7 enduro
- 2017 F350 (tow monster)

Gone but not forgotten
- 1986 944 (under new mgmt)
- 1991 944S2 (in car heaven...)
- 2001 Chevy Suburban 2500 (FIL's beast now)

"Keep your eyes on the road and your hands upon the wheel." - The Doors
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 06-12-2021, 10:17 AM
SRG SRG is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Charlottesville, Va.
Posts: 133
SRG
Default

Had a neighbor complain about MY tree falling on HER fence.

I told her that I was not so arrogant as to think that I owned things like trees, they belonged to god and that one was god's gift to her.

Last edited by SRG; 06-13-2021 at 09:58 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 06-12-2021, 10:47 AM
cmartin's Avatar
cmartin cmartin is offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Pasadena, MD
Posts: 7,404
cmartin
Default

Sorry I'm not closer, I'm always looking for firewood.

Good luck with the fence
__________________
78 SC, the 'Red Car'
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 06-12-2021, 12:36 PM
BillC's Avatar
BillC BillC is offline
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Silver Spring, MD
Posts: 1,138
BillC
Default

So I called the insurance company last night and filed a claim. They confirmed that the tree is our problem. So now we have to get quotes for fixing the fence, but that means waiting until Monday, since both the fence contractors and the claims adjuster won't be available until then. I'll probably just cut up the fallen wood myself, but not until I talk to the adjuster first.

Of course, the falling tree also did a number on the little tree that was planted just a couple of months ago -- tore a number of branches off it. So, we're going to have to see if the little tree makes it.
__________________
2016 GT4 warp 7
1999 SPB warp 2, maybe
1973 914 2.0 1/2 impulse

Previous:
1973 914 1.7 1/4 impulse
2012 Cayman R warp 4
2006 Cayman S warp 3
1966 911 stuck in space dock

Last edited by BillC; 06-12-2021 at 08:51 PM.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump